thinking

What the Extended Mind Does Well – And What It Doesn’t

What EM Does Well

Declarative Memory

It is relatively easy to dig up trivia and tidbits if you have a good enough archiving system and/or search engine. With biological memory, the information must be relatively significant to be remembered.

Volitional Recollection

Directly related to the above: it is difficult to volitionally remember many things, whereas digging them up from an archive is easy.

Information Management

Again, directly related to the above: information management is massively easier with pen and paper and libraries, not to speak of the digital realm. Furthermore, with the advent of ubiquitous connectivity, we can push the digital retrieval response times close to spontaneous recollection, which will no doubt produce interesting results.

Ubiquitous Availability

That is, of course, unless things crash or break apart. But digital technologies enable us an increasingly available access to EM capacities, whereas biological mental capacities are available variantly.

Task Management

Externalizing information works particularly well for tasks and other repetitive declarative information.

Organizing

Directly related to task and information management.

Generating Randomness

This should be rather obvious; the biological mind cannot produce genuine randomness. A program can.

Calculation

Once again, rather obvious: all rule-following is massively easier to an algorithm-driven program than to a human being.

Collective Thinking

This is only beginning to emerge, but we can do more and more together with the aid of EM technologies, whereas in biological connectivity, we are limited to very small groups.

Social Networking

Directly related to the above: real-time social networks are relatively small, whereas a digital network can consist of hundreds of active participants.

What EM Does Not Do Well

Creative Thinking

Machines do not as for now think creatively. Furthermore, while EM can augment creativity (think mind maps), it does not alone produce creative thought.

Emotions

This is actually more relevant to AI than EM; it is also arguable that EM can be used to induce and direct emotions. But once again, it is a subtle interplay between the biological mind and EM.

Reflection

It is very hard to think what would EM reflection even mean. Reflection is quite directly related to the biological mind, while of course it may involve EM components.

Metacognition

It seems metacognition is hard for both BM and EM. Perhaps a solution will emerge later? Thinking about thinking is not a very easy skill to learn, it appears.

Humor, analogies and irony

These require a human interpreter, and do not have an intrinsic EM dimension to them.

Evaluating Information

This is a field where EM will no doubt soon catch up. Nonetheless, right now automatic evaluation of information is still very elementary and gives a very varying mileage.

Standard

One thought on “What the Extended Mind Does Well – And What It Doesn’t

  1. Pingback: Extended Mind and Thinking Creatively « The Extended Mind

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s